Ebook Download Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose
Interested? Obviously, this is why, we intend you to click the web link web page to see, then you could appreciate guide Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose downloaded and install until finished. You could conserve the soft data of this Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose in your device. Naturally, you will bring the device everywhere, won't you? This is why, every time you have downtime, each time you could delight in reading by soft copy publication Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose
Ebook Download Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose. Modification your behavior to hang or squander the time to just chat with your buddies. It is done by your everyday, don't you feel burnt out? Currently, we will certainly show you the brand-new habit that, really it's an older behavior to do that can make your life a lot more qualified. When feeling bored of always talking with your pals all free time, you could discover guide qualify Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose and then review it.
This publication Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose is anticipated to be one of the most effective seller book that will certainly make you really feel pleased to purchase and read it for finished. As recognized could typical, every publication will certainly have specific things that will make an individual interested so much. Even it originates from the writer, kind, content, and even the author. Nonetheless, many individuals additionally take guide Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose based on the style as well as title that make them amazed in. and right here, this Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose is extremely recommended for you because it has fascinating title and also style to read.
Are you actually a fan of this Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose If that's so, why do not you take this publication now? Be the very first individual that like and also lead this book Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose, so you could get the factor and messages from this publication. Never mind to be confused where to obtain it. As the other, we discuss the connect to go to as well as download the soft data ebook Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose So, you may not lug the printed book Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose everywhere.
The existence of the on the internet publication or soft file of the Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose will certainly ease people to obtain guide. It will likewise conserve even more time to only look the title or writer or publisher to obtain up until your publication Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose is revealed. Then, you can visit the link download to visit that is provided by this website. So, this will be a very good time to start enjoying this book Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose to check out. Consistently good time with book Grant Under Fire: An Exposé Of Generalship & Character In The American Civil War, By Joseph A. Rose, constantly great time with money to spend!
A groundbreaking book challenges Ulysses S. Grant's reputation as a military genius and reliable chronicler of the Civil War. Grant has a sterling reputation as an officer and gentleman, despite suffering the biggest surprise of the war, committing the worst official act of anti-Semitism on U.S. soil, and coming closest of all Union commanders to losing Washington. Defenders even rank his generalship above Robert E. Lee's, but to do so, they must ignore his simplistic, pugnacious strategies that led to a war of attrition, as well as amateurish tactics of impetuous frontal assaults, all along the line against fortified positions. He relied on favoritism to decide military matters, trashing personal enemies, elevating friends, and arranging battle plans to fit his prejudices. Rigorously based on primary sources, it resolves such controversies as his drunken partying with the enemy on boats out of Cairo, Illinois, blaming Lew Wallace for a slow march to Shiloh, pretending that he had a plan to pass Vicksburg all along, taking credit for the charge up Missionary Ridge, and leaving wounded men to suffer between the lines at Cold Harbor. It overturns old tales by detailing Grant's corruption in Cairo, occupation of Paducah under orders, blunders in the Delta, and non-triumphal exit from the Wilderness. Grant's Memoirs are shown to be unreliable. Brave in battle and persistent on campaign, Grant achieved victory at Fort Donelson and Vicksburg by hedging in an inert enemy commander against a river. Naval forces-whose impact in the war he minimized-played a crucial role at each. He also refused to acknowledge the services of Elihu Washburne, John Rawlins, Charles Dana, and Henry Halleck. Besides describing Grant's flawed generalship and character, Grant Under Fire helps redeem the reputations of Robert E. Lee, John McClernand, Gouverneur Warren, George Thomas, William Rosecrans, Don Carlos Buell, George Meade, and others from 150 years of untruthful attacks.
- Sales Rank: #1675107 in Books
- Published on: 2015
- Binding: Hardcover
- 816 pages
Review
Impressively researched, "Grant Under Fire" is an iconoclastic but exceptionally well documented contribution to our clearer and more in-depth understanding of the role Grant played in the American Civil War. Informed and informative, "Grant Under Fire" is a seminal work of exhaustive scholarship and a critically important contribution to personal, community, and academic library American Civil War reference collections and supplemental studies reading lists.--Midwest Book Review
From the Inside Flap
Grant Under Fire is a thought-provoking study of the generalship and strategy of U.S. Grant during the Civil War. Joseph A. Rose convincingly argues that a close study of the historical record refutes Grant's reputation as a military genius and common sense strategist. Rose writes with a vigorous style, and supports his thesis with impressive research and incisive analysis.--Robert I. Girardi, author of The Soldiers' General: Major General Gouverneur K. Warren and the Civil War
Ulysses S. Grant has a sterling reputation as an officer and a gentleman, despite his suffering the biggest surprise of the Civil War, committing the worst official act of anti-Semitism on United States soil, and coming closest of all U.S. commanders to losing Washington. Defenders even rank his generalship above Robert E. Lee's, but to do so, they must ignore his simplistic, pugnacious strategies that led to a war of attrition, as well as his amateurish tactics of impetuous frontal assaults, all along the line against fortified positions.
Grant Under Fire comprehensively dissects his military career. Rigorously based on a wealth of primary sources--many not cited before--it resolves such controversies as his drunken partying with the enemy on flag-of-truce boats out of Cairo, Illinois, dishonestly blaming Lew Wallace for the slow march to Shiloh, pretending that he had the plan to pass Vicksburg all along, taking credit for the charge up Missionary Ridge, and leaving wounded men to suffer and die between the lines at Cold Harbor. It overturns familiar tales, detailing Grant's corruption in Cairo, occupation of Paducah under orders, blunders in the Mississippi Delta, and the non-triumphal exit from the Wilderness. Grant's Personal Memoirs are shown to be essentially unreliable.
Personally brave in battle and persistent on campaign, Grant achieved victory at Fort Donelson and Vicksburg by hedging in an inert southern commander against a river. Naval forces--whose impact in the war he minimized--played a crucial role at each. He likewise refused to acknowledge his dependence on the services of Elihu Washburne, John A. Rawlins, Charles A. Dana, Henry Halleck, and many others for their part in his triumphs.
Usually ignored or glossed over by many partisan biographers, a lazy, disorganized, negligent, and unjust Ulysses Grant held grudges, played politics, over-indulged in alcohol, and managed public relations with his pet reporters. His lesser-known failings included stealing rival John McClernand's Mississippi expedition, allowing lessees of plantations to exploit newly freed slaves, keeping Black troops out of combat, perpetrating the worst insubordination by a General-in-Chief in lobbying for Andrew Johnson's impeachment, and abrogating treaties with Native Americans, which led to the Black Hills War. While president, Grant looked the other way as his crooked friends stole from the government.
Besides describing the flawed generalship and character of Grant and his protégés, such as William Tecumseh Sherman and Philip Sheridan, Grant Under Fire helps redeem the reputations of Robert E. Lee, John A. McClernand, Gouverneur Warren, George H. Thomas, William S. Rosecrans, Don Carlos Buell, Jacob Lauman, George G. Meade, and others from over 150 years of biased and untruthful attacks.
From the Back Cover
Advance Praise for Grant Under Fire
Joseph Rose's provocative account of U.S. Grant's military career offers a valuable and much needed corrective to the currently prevailing view of Grant's actions and accomplishments. Rose's prodigious and impeccable scholarship greatly strengthens his penetrating analysis of both Grant the man and Grant the commander. Future writers on Grant would do well to take Rose's work into account.--William Glenn Robertson, author of Back Door to Richmond: The Bermuda Hundred Campaign, April-June 1864 and The Petersburg Campaign: The Battle of Old Men and Young Boys, June 9, 1864
Popular history is notable for many inaccuracies and distortions by prominent figures who had an agenda to promote. U. S. Grant was no exception. As Joseph Rose portrays herein, the many controversies involving Grant's military failures and mistakes are worthy of re-examination. Just to set the record straight, there should be more future insightful research and commentary, as you will find here.--Wiley Sword, author of Shiloh: Bloody April and Embrace an Angry Wind: The Confederacy's Last Hurrah: Spring Hill, Franklin, and Nashville and Mountains Touched with Fire: Chattanooga Besieged, 1863
A well-written, exhaustively researched essay on how many errors and sins a commander can commit and still stand among the Great Captains of history.--John Horn, author of The Siege of Petersburg: The Battles for the Weldon Railroad, August 1864 and The Petersburg Campaign, May 1864-April 1865
The Personal Memoirs of Ulysses S. Grant, though hailed as one of the greatest military memoirs ever written and generally accepted by professional historians as a fundamental primary source on America's Civil War, is now being challenged. ... Rose examines the truthfulness of Grant's account for the entire conflict. Grant Under Fire reveals a general with a dramatically different character than the one he portrayed for himself.--Lawrence Lee Hewitt, author of Port Hudson, Confederate Bastion on the Mississippi and co-editor of the three-volume Confederate Generals in the Western Theater
Bound to create animated discussion among avid Civil War buffs, Grant Under Fire is an insightful alternative view of Grant's leadership, based on author Joseph Rose's extensive research.--David Cleutz, author of Fields of Fame and Glory: Col. David Ireland & 137th New York Volunteers and Rebels in the Front Yard: Liberty at Gettysburg
Recent scholarship has indicated that much of what we thought we knew about the Civil War is not, in fact, the truth. This carefully-researched and engagingly-written book contributes a great deal to our knowledge of what really happened on some of the most famous battlefields of that conflict. It is a must for any serious student of the Civil War.--Frank Varney, author of General Grant and the Rewriting of History: How the Destruction of General William S. Rosecrans Influenced Our Understanding of the Civil War
Joseph Rose presents an engaging critical assessment of Grant's generalship that is destined to provoke lively debate among students of America's bloodiest conflict. One might disagree with Rose's conclusions, but his careful scholarship demands that they receive serious consideration.--Gordon Rhea, author of The Battle of the Wilderness, May 5-6, 1864 and Cold Harbor: Grant and Lee, May 26-June 3, 1864
Most helpful customer reviews
19 of 24 people found the following review helpful.
Excellent Job Using the Primary Sources
By Bryce A. Suderow
I am Bryce A. Suderow, author of "The Petersburg Campaign" a two volume history of the Siege of Petersburg that won the Douglas Southall Freeman Award in 2014 for best Civil War book of the year.
Since my expertise is the Siege of Petersburg, I'll address myself to Rose's section on that campaign.
I'm impressed by the thorough job Rose did in researching the correspondence volumes in the Official Records. By citing Grant's correspondence he demonstrates how again and again Grant threw together badly planned campaigns that were bound to fail. To my mind this proves that Grant was not a good battlefield general.
I'm also impressed by Rose's clarity and his restraint. Instead of sneering at Grant, he simply delivers the facts and lets them speak for thsmselves.
13 of 16 people found the following review helpful.
This book will help the whole truth of the American Civil War come to light.
By David M
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War
This book about U.S. Grant is important in the study of the American Civil War because it details the shortcomings of the General not only in his handling of the war, but especially in his conduct as an officer and a gentleman. Ever since the creation of West Point for the training of a professional officer corps, it had been drilled into each officer that the only path to advancement other than the normal path of seniority, was outstanding performance on the battlefield. This required that senior officers give an honest evaluation of the performance of subordinate officers in their reports such that the best officers could be rewarded. It was a point of honor that these reports would be scrupulously fair and unbiased. It was important that the best officers bubble up quickly not only to win battles and the war but to protect the fighting men from incompetent officers.
For the first time the details of Grant's decisions and deceptions are shown with footnoted clarity. The 'tactics' he employed in his climb to the top command of the Army was a far cry from the principles taught at West Point.
He ruined the careers of several good officers by scapegoating his mistakes on them. He requested promotions for undeserving cronies into senior positions and derailed the careers of rivals he feared. It may never be known how many union soldiers died because of such decisions.
General Grant will always be known as the general who led the Union to victory, but as historian Stephen Z. Starr has stated, “...as a commander of armies, and above all, as a human being, Grant had shortcomings so fundamental as to negate his right to occupy the very high place his modern-day admirers have sought to award to him.”
This book will help the whole truth of the American Civil War come to light.
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful.
An exhaustively detailed indictment of Ulysses S. Grant
By Zachary
This book is centered around the argument that General Ulysses Grant was not the great general and man that many other historical works have made him out to be. In this volume of close to 800 pages, Mr. Rose makes that argument with a mountain of research that details countless examples of Grant's faults, mistakes, blunders, misrepresentations and even venality.
Mr. Rose goes after his subject with relentless precision while covering all of Grant's major campaigns and battles. What emerges is a Grant that is nothing like the conquering hero of historical myth, but a fallible and terribly flawed man whose achievements and capabilities are questioned at every turn.
I am a history aficionado, but have no compelling interest in the Civil War and little background as to Grant's qualities as a commander. Consequently, I have no "dog in the fight" as to the fairness of Mr. Rose's depiction of Grant. Still, GRANT UNDER FIRE is impressive in its scope and comprehensiveness, and provides meticulous detail for those who wish to venture into the depths of research on this American icon. This is not light, fast reading, with breezy overviews; rather, it takes a more scholarly approach, with straightforward elucidation of the events of Grant's career. Hence, the book seems perfect for hardcore Civil War buffs and historians who might have some of their cherished ideas of Grant thrown into disarray. Is Grant a hero and a military genius, or a mediocre soldier and a man with feet of clay? Before you decide, you may want to read this book.
See all 13 customer reviews...
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose PDF
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose EPub
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Doc
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose iBooks
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose rtf
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Mobipocket
Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Kindle
> Ebook Download Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Doc
> Ebook Download Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Doc
> Ebook Download Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Doc
> Ebook Download Grant Under Fire: An Exposé of Generalship & Character in the American Civil War, by Joseph A. Rose Doc
